Hashnayim Garden

A series of observations and a comprehensive public engagement process turned what was initially planned as a light intervention into a significant renovation of a central garden in Jaffa. Through collaboration with residents, layers of history, emotions, and the community’s strong connection to the garden and its surroundings were brought to light.

The project began as an initiative by Mishlama Jaffa to replace the play equipment in a central garden in the heart of the Ajami neighborhood. Initially, the plan was limited to upgrading the equipment. However, observations of the garden and its surroundings revealed a vibrant hub of activity, with heavy pedestrian traffic and diverse groups of people of all ages using the space. Conversations with visitors underscored the garden’s importance, highlighting its historical and social significance to the community. It became evident that the community’s needs went far beyond replacing play equipment, and that additional stakeholders needed to be involved. To guide the intervention, we launched a public engagement process aimed at identifying barriers, opportunities, and actionable insights. A festive public event was held in the garden, featuring activity stations where over 550 responses were collected regarding potential uses, preferred features, and residents’ sentiments about the space. Focus groups were also conducted with neighborhood residents, and we also met with local community leaders to gather additional input.

The findings revealed the community’s strong desire to preserve the garden as a space for gatherings and social interactions. Residents expressed an emotional connection to the garden, rooted in its long-standing history, its role as a hub for community interactions, and its legacy as a historic meeting place for Jaffa’s fishermen. At the same time, residents raised concerns about safety and the garden’s overall condition, pointing to outdated and hazardous play equipment, unregulated traffic, a lack of seating, poor maintenance and cleanliness, and insufficient gardening work.

This process highlighted the garden’s profound importance to residents and provided the rationale for increasing the municipal budget for its renovation. Recognizing that simply installing new equipment would fail to address the deeper needs of the community, we partnered with the City Beautification Department to design a comprehensive transformation

Community feedback was distilled into actionable insights and integrated into the renovation plan, alongside Urban95 principles for creating public spaces that encourage play and cater to the needs of young children and their caregivers. Throughout the year-long renovation, we maintained open communication with the community, sharing the results of the public engagement process, publishing the finalized plan, and displaying detailed explanations of the project on signage around the construction site.

.

Participating municipal units: The Community, Culture, and Sports Administration; Mishlama Jaffa; the City Beautification Department.

Hashnayim Garden, post-renovation (photo by Ilan Safira)

Impact

  • High usage of the garden: The garden is now actively used daily, with residents expressing satisfaction and enthusiasm for the transformation. Significant improvement was seen across all relevant parameters.
  • Strong community participation despite challenges: Hundreds of residents of all ages took part in the public engagement process, even though the event occurred during the COVID-19 pandemic and amidst Operation Guardian of the Walls and incidents of violence in Jaffa.
  • Solutions tailored to the community’s needs: The public engagement process allowed for tailored responses, such as the creation of an outdoor classroom now used by nearby kindergartens and schools.
  • The garden’s redesign has made it a vibrant space for meaningful community gatherings and activities.

What we learned along the way

  • Observations drove the transformation: The data revealed that the space served a diverse and extensive user base, providing clear evidence that shifted perceptions and helped secure funding to meet the community’s needs.
  • Resident engagement throughout the process fosters a sense of ownership, encourages public responsibility, and reduces vandalism. Designing tailored solutions that align with the community’s needs builds connections and garners resident support.
קרדיט: אילן ספירא

The project was created and operated in partnership with

Hashnayim Garden - Public participation planning procedure